The Quatermass All-Purpose Media Review Thread

Welcome to the Sir Terry Pratchett Forums
Register here for the Sir Terry Pratchett forum and message boards.
Sign up

Quatermass

Sergeant-at-Arms
Dec 7, 2010
8,022
2,950
REVIEW: Chainsaw Man Episode 1: Dog & Chainsaw, Episode 2: Arrival in Tokyo, Episode 3: Meowy’s Whereabouts and Episode 4: Rescue by Hiroshi Seko, from the manga series by Tatsuki Fujimoto

TYPE: TV series

DETAILS: CSM1.1-1.4, 4X25 minute episodes

Chainsaw Man was one of those manga series that grew on me, albeit like a fungus at first. But it went from strength to strength, and I felt it was time to start the anime adaptation, created by MAPPA who also adapted Attack on Titan. But how would it fare?

In a world living in fear of Devils, teenager Denji is making a living killing them to pay a debt he owes the Yakuza thanks to his late father. He is helped by his only friend, a cute Devil known as Pochita, a dog-like creature with a chainsaw snout. After being betrayed and murdered by the Yakuza, Denji is revived by Pochita, and becomes the Chainsaw Man, a Devil Hybrid. Conscripted by the alluring and sinister Makima of Public Safety into becoming a Devil-Hunter for the Japanese government, Denji needs to figure out what his dreams in life are…

It feels like the adaptors took what was good about the manga, and polished it to a mirror shine. True, it’s still in the stage where the plot is finding traction, some of the humour (especially where Denji’s obsession with sexual activity is concerned) falls very flat, and there’s questionable character interaction. But they manage to polish, if not a turd, then something that was mediocre or average in its initial stages, and make it better.

The casting is superlative. True, Denji’s obsession with breasts gets old quickly, but Ryan Colt Levey infuses the crass, socially-impaired teen with relatable humanity. Reagan Murdock does well as Aki, a character I admittedly despise at this early stage. Yet aside from Levey, the stars in particular as Suzie Yeung as Makima and Sarah Wiedenheft as Power. Yeung infuses Makima with maternal warmth that can switch to cold pragmatism in the blink of an eye, all in the same gentle tones, while Wiedenheft channels Japanese voice actress Farouz Ai in doing a fun and chaotic take on Power who remains more human than the Blood Fiend would like.

The production values are where the series truly shines. Drawing on experience from Attack on Titan and other shows, MAPPA gives the series an energetic nature in a nonetheless realistic setting. The chaos of the opening titles, the cinematography of the quiet moments, the battles between Denji and first the Bat Devil, and then the Leech Devil, are great.

Chainsaw Man’s initial episodes take what is in the manga and polish it to a gleam. Not perfect by any means, but an impressive improvement all the same…

****
 

Quatermass

Sergeant-at-Arms
Dec 7, 2010
8,022
2,950
REVIEW: Avatar: The Last Airbender Book 1- Water, Chapter 4: The Warriors of Kyoshi, Chapter 5: The King of Omashu, and Chapter 6: Imprisoned by Nick Malis, John O’Bryan, and Matthew Hubbard

TYPE: TV series

DETAILS: ATLA1.4-1.6, 3X25 minute episodes

So, here we are, with my embarking on more episodes of Avatar: The Last Airbender. But after an enjoyable beginning, how would these episodes fare? Let’s find out…

Aang and his friends’ quest have meandered somewhat. A stayover in Kyoshi, founded by one of Aang’s predecessors, nearly leads to disaster when Aang lets his fame goes to his head. A stop in Omashu brings back memories for Aang, and leaves them prey to the elderly and crazed king of the city. And when they come across a village whose Earthbenders have been imprisoned by the Fire Nation, Katara makes a mistake that will see her willingly go to prison to make up for it…

After the excitement of the first few episodes, I have to confess, the next lot were a bit of a letdown, with the rather simplistic morality and character development. True, this is a kid’s show, and the episodes aren’t bad, I was just expecting more. The particular highlight was the second episode, giving a window into Aang’s past, and introducing the fun character of King Bumi of Omashu.

The main voice cast do well in their roles, even if Sokka’s chauvinism gets old really quickly in the first episode. However, Andre Sogliuzzo is a delight as the seemingly-deranged Bumi. I do feel George Takei was wasted in the third episode: an actor of his calibre seems to be overqualified to play the Prison Warden in that episode, as much as Takei gave the role an air of urbane menace as a thin veneer over his cruelty.

The production values are pretty good. True, it’s not a patch on many modern animated series, Japanese or otherwise, but it does a damn good job for not only its time, but now. One particular highlight is the second episode, with the high-speed chute ride and the final battle between Aang and Bumi in particular getting my notice.

Overall, while not as great as the first set of episodes, these were enough to keep my interest. Let’s hope the next set gets better…


***½
 

User Menu

Newsletter